Stacey Hoffer, Indiana University of Pennsylvania

Exhumed or Erased? Anne Brontë and the Brontë Myth 


The above link will take you to a recording of the presentation. 


Abstract: 

Myths circulate around and obscure the Brontë Sisters like mist over the moors. Perhaps because of this, like Heathcliff, modern readers can't help but exhume their beloved Brontës. As time and careful scholarship slowly strip away superficial mythologies, they reveal bone-deep truths about what their writing represents and what it means to be alive. 


In Dead or Alive, Adam Phillips asks what we sacrifice to feel alive and whether that feeling can be sustained. By contrast, the Brontë myth is a sacrificial masterclass, a habitual tactic so prevalent it collapses three distinct, combative women into a single, legible silhouette. But what haunts the periphery? 


Charlotte purposefully perpetuated these myths. Whether protective or otherwise, she casts both Anne and Emily as misunderstood misanthropes rather than mistresses of their fate. They emerge as the myth's most instructive casualties. Emily gets mythologized upward into abstraction as a masculinized genius or mystic recluse, so extravagantly vivid in cultural memory she ceases to remain human. Anne, however, gets mythologized downward and largely erased. Charlotte's posthumous program promotes her piety and presupposed longing for death in spite of the words Anne left behind to the contrary. Instead, Charlotte withdraws The Tenant of Wildfell Hall, calling her most radical work a mistake, framing her as misguided but well-meaning. As a result, Anne sinks beneath the weight of the Brontë Myth, receiving less critical and scholarly attention, a mere footnote in the strange Brontëan hierarchy scholarship continues to perpetuate. 


Despite this lack of study, Anne is perhaps the most Phillips-ian Brontë. Recovered through Samantha Ellis's Take Courage and the historical record scholars such as Barker and Miller painstakingly assemble, Anne begins to emerge triumphant. Examination of her poetry and prose reveal hidden depths in this most neglected of the sisterhood. She is Hope as a discipline, Hope with her fists up, almost defiant as she fights for survival. Anne teaches her readers how to live, choosing painful truth over pleasing story and saying so explicitly, but quietly, in print. She understood, better than the myth could capture, what it actually costs to stay alive, striking shafts of sunlight through the moorish mists and burning off their obscuring clouds.


Presenter bio:

Stacey Hoffer is an Instructional Coordinator in the English Department at Delaware Technical Community College, Wilmington Campus. Former president of the Mid-Atlantic Writing Center Association and Board Member of the International Writing Center Association, she is a doctoral candidate in the Indiana University of Pennsylvania's Literary Criticism PhD program. A practitioner of the dark arts of domesticity, she lives in Delaware with her three cats, two children, and partner. Look for her publications in Chickpea Magazine and Interweave.

A smiling person wearing clear glasses and green earrings.