Between Fanaa and Baqaa: Mystical Poetry as the Practice of Aliveness
The above link will take you to a recording of the presentation.
Abstract:
Deadness shows up in recognizable ways: in the numbing fog of monotony, in moral anesthesia, in forgetting childlike wonder, and distraction in moments of awe. For literary analysts it takes the form of theoretical imposition on living texts, reciting poetry in a monotone, reproduction of sameness until ideas stop being alive and start being ornaments. Although psychoanalysts D. W. Winnicott and Adam Phillips consider the developmental and existential conditions of death in life, neither thinker fully accounts for the psychic reality of mystical experience, what mystical texts actually produce in the body and mind of the reader. This lecture proposes that Sufi and other mystical poetry has been living inside that question for centuries.
Drawing on Michael Sells exploration of fanaa and baqaa across Sufi literature, this lecture maps the themes of annihilation and return, descent and subsistence, the ego dissolved so something more essential can remain. Four poets provide examples to build the premise of how mystical expression nudges the boundary between deadness and aliveness rather than resolving it. Rumi's reed, cut from its bed, cries from the wound and the lament becomes music. Rabia al-Adawiyya, stripping away every false consolation until only bare attention remains. Bulleh Shah dissolves every fixed category of identity through dance and defiance. Finally, Mahsati Ganjavi finds holiness in the open embodiment of desire. Her work remains difficult to access in English translation which raises ethical concerns in this lecture about female authorship in mystical tradition. Jung's theories of necessary descent and rebirth run beneath all four, giving the movement from deadness toward aliveness another psycho-spiritual layer. This presentation focuses on how mystical poets dwell on the question of dead or alive and encourages the audience to sit with both states long enough to glimpse what lies beyond them.
Presenter bio:
Mahrukh Hamid is a doctoral student of Literature and Criticism from Pakistan, returning to Indiana University of Pennsylvania after completing her masters in 2025. She served as the Digital Archivist for AHSA archive digitization project, Treasurer for English Graduate Organization (2024-25), and co-initiated Creative Mix (a cross-disciplinary gathering for students to create art). She also acted as the Staff Editor for Oak Grove Review (2025), an IUP student-led literary magazine.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.