Joshua Calandrella, Indiana University of Pennsylvania

The Myth of Being Left Out: Mad Men with Musical Genius in The Phantom of the Opera and Overture to Glory


The above link will take you to a recording of the presentation. 


Abstract: 

In this lecture I reimagine the myth of the musical genius through an investigation of the

tragic hero and how he attempts, fails, and succeeds to integrate rejection through a

renewed identity formation inspired by his desire to compose. Whereas Gaston Leroux’s

French serial detective novel, The Phantom of the Opera (1910), relies on allusions to

popular nineteenth-century myths adapted for French opera (Faust, Don Juan) the

American Yiddish film, Overture to Glory (1940), directed by Max Nosseck, capture the

multilingual overlap between Jews, gentiles, sacred liturgy, and nationalist opera. Leroux

weaves fictional documentarian evidence with character witness testimony to resolve the

mysterious identity of the Opera Ghost and his relationship to Christine Daaé, a young

soprano whose disappears with her fiancé Raul, the Vicomte de Chaney, after the

discovery of the corpse of his brother, Count Philipe; however, the Phantom is a man

named Erik, a disfigured composer, violinist, and vocalists living below the lower

mezzanine. Likewise, Overture to Glory depicts the tragedy of Yoel Duvid Strashunsky, the

historic cantor who left Vilna to study Polish Opera in Warsaw and suffered a tragic death

from consumption and melancholia after the death of his children. Although Erik and Yoel

Duvid create masterworks of art, they are unable to compose a stable life—stuck between

heaven and earth, the Opera house and the shul. Because they reject the possibility to

experience pleasure through their creations, they become tragic heroes, who, in the words

of psychoanalyst Adam Phillips, “creates havoc... and tries to solve the problem of

exclusion by seeking to exclude his excluders, in retaliation.” Thus, musical genius, no

longer just a man, transforms into a lasting legend through his madness and monstrosity, a

broken vessel that ensure the belonging of the legacy of his art, but never the genius

himself.

Man with dreadlocks sitting by a window overlooking a river.

Presenter bio:

Joshua Patrick Calandrella is a PhD candidate in Literature and Criticism at Indiana

University of Pennsylvania. His literary studies weave together the regrowth of twentieth-century Yiddish Poetry after the Holocaust and the layering of Jewish literary history across

space and time. He also studies Biblical Hebrew, Chassidic literature, World Mythology,

Latin American Literature, and the interweaving of Romanticism and Mysticism in European

and American novels. When he is not teaching English Composition at the University of

Pittsburgh Johnstown, Joshua writes poetry and co-teaches with the IUP Yiddish club in

surrealist yeshiva.