Is There a Doctor in the House?: Overlap Between the Life and Death Instincts in Vasily Grossman’s Life and Fate
Access to video link available upon request.
Abstract:
In “Dead or Alive,” psychoanalyst Adam Phillips poses questions about what we sacrifice to feel alive and what we deaden to survive. Vasily Grossman’s 1959 novel, Life and Fate, covers issues related to Phillips’ questions as it explores the lives of people navigating Nazi and Soviet totalitarianism. Grossman’s novel follows regular people facing moral issues as they confront anti-Semitism and Soviet communism, with one recurring theme being senseless kindness amidst unspeakable horrors. Many characters strive to maintain humanity by engaging in small acts of compassion. Phillips contends that to feel alive “requires a sacrifice of sorts” (Phillips, “Dead or Alive”). For Sofya, the thing she has to give up to feel alive is paradoxically life itself. When an SS officer says, “Doctors, surgeons, come forward!” (Grossman 540), doctors were being temporarily spared from the gas chambers so they could preserve the labor force and prevent epidemics. Sofya, a doctor, remains silent, remaining with a young boy rather than saving herself. She sacrifices life to feel alive, choosing to become a mother figure to the parentless David.
Sigmund Freud’s 1920 book Beyond the Pleasure Principle introduced two seemingly opposing human drives, the “life instinct” and the “death instinct” (Freud 43). Although Sofya’s actions seem to represent the death drive, I argue her choices are closer to the life instinct, which is associated with love and social bonding. I will demonstrate how Grossman’s novel extends Freud’s theories regarding life and death, showing that when death is used to control humanity, human kindness has the power to overturn the death instinct. Grossman shows us how there is overlap between the life and death instincts driven by a desire not just to die in one’s own way but to maintain integrity and compassion even in a world that dehumanizes, demoralizes, and destroys human lives.
.png/:/cr=t:0%25,l:0%25,w:100%25,h:100%25/rs=w:400,cg:true)
Baylie Jett Mills is a doctoral student in the English Literature and Criticism program at Indiana University of Pennsylvania. She recently earned her MA in English from Texas Tech University. Baylie’s research focuses on 19th through 21st-century American literature and trauma studies, including paths toward healing from trauma. She has been published in Western American Literature, ANQ: A Quarterly Journal of Short Articles, Notes and Reviews, Sigma Tau Delta Review, Harbinger: A Journal of Art and Literature, Watermark Journal, and International Journal of Basic, Applied, and Multidisciplinary Research.
.png/:/rs=w:400,cg:true,m)
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.